Fresh Seafood.

Long Island’s Local Catches.

Off The Bay. On Point.

New American Tavern serving fresh local seafood right Off The Bay.

Metal platter with oysters, shrimp, diced seafood and avocado salad, and three dipping sauces on ice.

Coastal Flavors, Elevated

A menu rooted in fresh, local ingredients and coastal influence. Experience vibrant seafood, refined classics, and bold flavors—all served with a modern edge.

View Menu ➛
Handcrafted cocktails on a wooden picnic table

Handcrafted Cocktails

A lineup of craft cocktails, each artfully mixed with fresh ingredients

View Menu ➛

Anchor Your Events Here.

From laid back gatherings to high energy celebrations, Off The Bay is where great food, crafted cocktails, and unforgettable moments come together. There is always something happening here in the heart of Sayville.

View Menu ➛

Happy Hour

Half price happy hour 6 days a week, noon til 6pm.
ALL DAY on Sundays.

Happy Hour Menu

Sayville Sundays

‍
Our top-shelf happy hour extended ALL DAY.
From open 'til close Every Sunday.

‍

HALF OFF All Drinks & Small Plates Menu

View Small Plates Menu
Varied cocktails and appetizer plates including wings, sliders, croquettes, and small dishes on a dark table.
Gift Card

Gift Cards

Order a digital gift card for Off The Bay, Frankie’s Table, and WhiskeyNeat.
Order Now
Off The Bay - Sayville logoReserve a Table
Copyright © 202X Off The Bay. All Rights Reserved.
Off The Bay - Sayville logo